Skip to main content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

CoJo 212: Rhetorical Criticism: Magazines vs Journals

A course guide for CoJo 212

Scholarly Journal

  • Audience - scholars in academic field

  • Readers have some understanding of the subject

  • Articles are refereed: must contribute to the existing body of knowledge in the field

  • Authors experts in the field

  • Generally no advertising, not a profit making enterprise

  • Generally few, if any pictures

  • Distributed mostly by subscription

Magazines Vs Journals

 

 

What is a "Refereed" (Peer-Reviewed) article?

Refereed, or peer-reviewed articles are ones which are reviewed by a board of editors who are expert in a given field.These readers/editors determine if the material submitted for publication adds something significant to a body of knowledge that already exists. Refereed (or peer-reviewed) materials are important to the research and the literature of most academic fields; they assure readers that the information conveyed is reliable and timely.

Note:
The term "scholarly materials" is often used to describe refereed (or peer-reviewed) materials. However,the term is not exclusive to refereed material. While non-refereed materials may not by scrutinized as intensely as refereed materials, they can still be considered scholarly (or academic)!

Magazine

  • Audience is general public

  • No previous knowledge is required
     
  • Articles must help sell the magazine
     
  • Authors are not necessarily experts
     
  • Carries lots of advertising, probably more than editorial content
     
  • Lots of glossy pictures
     
  • For sale at newsstands