You'll often hear "explore the literature" or "what does the literature say?" So, what is "the literature?"
Most simply put, "the literature" is a collection of scholarly writings on a topic. This includes:
Synthesis in a literature review involves combining information from multiples sources to create a new, cohesive understanding of the research topic, rather than just summarizing individual studies.
What is synthesis? | What synthesis is NOT: |
|
|
The following table, developed by the University of Toronto Libraries, displays the similarities and differences between the most common types of reviews. This table was adapted from a variety of sources (Booth, 2016; Grant and Booth, 2009; Higgins & Green, 2011; Pham et al., 2014; and Tricco et al., 2015)
Knowledge synthesis |
A priori protocol required? |
Protocol registration required? |
Comprehensive search? |
Duplicate screening & data extraction? |
Critical appraisal? |
Statistical analysis? |
Time |
Systematic Review |
YES, often published |
YES |
YES |
YES |
YES |
1+ yr |
|
Meta Analysis |
YES, often published |
YES |
YES |
YES |
YES |
1+ yr |
|
Scoping Review |
YES |
JBI, OSF, Research Registry & other registries |
YES |
YES |
NO |
NO, charted evidence |
~ 1 yr |
Rapid Review |
YES, often not published |
OSF, Research Registry, & other registries |
NO, varied # of databases, dates and other limits |
Varied |
NO, but recommended |
NO, varied analysis methods |
~1 - 6 mo |
Realist Review |
YES, some published |
OSF, Research Registry, & other registries |
YES |
YES |
NO |
NO |
1+ yr |
Overview of reviews |
YES, often published |
YES, only reviews included |
YES |
YES |
YES |
~ 1 yr |
|
Mapping Review |
Encouraged |
OSF, Research Registry, & other registries |
YES |
Varied |
NO |
NO |
1+ yr |
Narrative Review |
NO |
Not necessary |
Varied, not necessary |
Varied, not necessary |
NO |
NO |
6 mo - 1 yr |
© 2023 University of St. Thomas, Minnesota